Self-relevance effect

Category:

Too Much Information

Definition:

Information that is personally relevant to an individual is more likely to be remembered.

Published on
September 4, 2024
Updated on
September 4, 2024
Too Much Information

Learning Objectives

What you will learn:
Understand the concept of the Self-relevance effect
Recognize the Impact of the Self-relevance effect in cybersecurity
Strategies to mitigate Self-relevance effect

Other Cognitive Biases

Author

Joshua Crumbaugh
Joshua Crumbaugh
Social Engineer

Subscribe to our newsletter

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

The Psychology behind the Self-relevance effect:

Cognitive biases operate as systematic deviations in our judgment, shaping how we perceive and interact with the world around us. The cognitive bias that highlights the prominence of bizarre, funny, visually striking, or anthropomorphic stimuli in memory retention underscores the brain's intrinsic affinity for novelty and emotional engagement. This phenomenon suggests that our cognitive architecture is wired to prioritize unusual or attention-grabbing information, which can trigger heightened emotional responses or curiosity. Consequently, these distinctive characteristics make such information more memorable, as they engage our senses and evoke emotional reactions that foster deeper processing.


This bias stands in contrast to the self-relevance effect, which posits that information closely tied to an individual's identity or personal experiences is more easily recalled. While the self-relevance effect emphasizes the role of personal connection in memory retention, the bias concerning bizarre or striking information illustrates how external attributes can independently capture attention and enhance recall. For example, an amusing advertisement or a visually captivating image can transcend personal relevance, resonating with a broader audience due to its inherent qualities. This distinction highlights the complexity of memory formation, revealing that both personal relevance and the striking nature of information contribute to our cognitive landscape, albeit through different mechanisms. Understanding these dynamics is essential for leveraging effective communication strategies, particularly in fields where capturing attention and retaining information are critical, such as education, marketing, and cybersecurity.

How To Differentiate the Self-relevance effect from other cognitive biases?

The cognitive bias of bizarre, funny, visually striking, or anthropomorphic things standing out more than non-bizarre or unfunny information is distinct because it highlights the role of novelty and emotional engagement in memory retention, rather than personal relevance. While the self-relevance effect emphasizes how information tied to an individual's identity or experiences enhances recall, the former bias focuses on the inherent qualities of the information itself that capture attention. This distinction underscores how external characteristics can influence memory independently of an individual's personal connection to the content.

How does the Self-relevance effect apply to Business Operations?

Scenario:

A cybersecurity firm launches a new phishing awareness campaign aimed at educating employees about the dangers of phishing attacks. The campaign includes various training materials, such as videos, infographics, and quizzes. However, the firm decides to incorporate a series of humorous and visually striking animations featuring quirky characters that personify phishing attacks and their consequences.


Application:

The use of bizarre and funny characters effectively captures the attention of employees, making the training more engaging. Instead of standard training materials that focus solely on statistics and risks, the campaign leverages humor and visual appeal, ensuring that employees remember the key messages. For example, one animation depicts a comical fish character trying to "hook" unsuspecting employees with deceptive emails.


Results:

After implementing the campaign, the cybersecurity firm conducts a follow-up survey and assessment. Results show a significant increase in employees' ability to identify phishing attempts, with retention rates for the training material rising by over 50% compared to previous campaigns. Employees report that the humorous and visually striking elements made the training more memorable and enjoyable.


Conclusion:

This example illustrates how the cognitive bias highlighting the prominence of bizarre and funny information can be leveraged in cybersecurity training. By creating engaging and striking content, businesses can enhance memory retention and awareness of cybersecurity threats. This approach not only fosters a more informed workforce but also promotes a culture of vigilance, ultimately reducing the risk of successful phishing attacks within the organization.


How do Hackers Exploit the Self-relevance effect?

Scenario:

A social engineer devises a plan to manipulate employees at a large corporation into divulging sensitive information. The social engineer creates a fake email campaign that appears to come from the company's IT department, featuring bizarre and humorous graphics to grab attention. The emails include striking images of anthropomorphic IT equipment that "pleads" for employees to help resolve a fictitious system issue.


Application:

The social engineer leverages the cognitive bias of bizarre and funny information to increase the likelihood that employees will engage with the emails. By utilizing visually striking content, the emails stand out in crowded inboxes, prompting employees to open them. The humorous tone and quirky characters create a false sense of familiarity and trust, making employees more likely to comply with requests for sensitive information, such as passwords or personal identification details.


Results:

After the email campaign, the social engineer successfully obtains sensitive information from several employees, who report that the emails were memorable and entertaining. The unusual content obscured the malicious intent, leading to a significant breach of the company’s cybersecurity protocols. The organization later reviews the incident and discovers that the unusual and humorous elements were key in bypassing employees' usual skepticism regarding unsolicited requests for information.


Conclusion:

This example illustrates how social engineers can exploit the cognitive bias favoring bizarre and funny information to manipulate individuals into compromising security protocols. By understanding how novelty and emotional engagement can influence memory and decision-making, businesses must implement robust training programs that raise awareness about such tactics and emphasize vigilance against unconventional phishing attempts. Enhancing employee skepticism towards unusual requests is crucial in safeguarding sensitive information and protecting against social engineering attacks.


How To Minimize the effect of the Self-relevance effect across your organization?

Defending against the cognitive bias that favors bizarre, funny, visually striking, or anthropomorphic information requires a multi-faceted approach, particularly in the context of cybersecurity. To mitigate the risks posed by this bias, organizations must cultivate a culture of critical thinking and skepticism among employees. This can be achieved through comprehensive training programs that not only educate staff on the mechanics of cognitive biases but also provide them with practical tools to identify and question unusual or attention-grabbing content. By encouraging employees to scrutinize communications that deviate from the norm, organizations can reduce the likelihood of successful phishing attacks and other forms of social engineering that exploit this bias.


Management plays a crucial role in preventing the exploitation of cognitive biases in operations. Leaders should prioritize clear communication channels and establish standardized procedures for verifying the authenticity of unusual requests for information. Implementing a robust verification process—such as requiring multiple forms of authentication or the use of secure communication platforms—can act as a safeguard against attempts to manipulate employees through bizarre or humorous content. By fostering an environment where employees feel empowered to question and verify unusual communications, organizations can create a barrier against cognitive biases that might otherwise compromise security protocols.


Additionally, organizations should continuously evaluate and update their training materials and phishing awareness campaigns to reflect the evolving nature of cyber threats. Incorporating real-world examples of how social engineers exploit cognitive biases can enhance the relevance of training content, making it more relatable and impactful for employees. By emphasizing the importance of remaining vigilant in the face of attention-grabbing tactics, management can reinforce the need for skepticism and critical thinking, thereby reducing the risk of employees falling victim to manipulative schemes.


Finally, fostering an organizational culture that values ongoing education and awareness about cybersecurity threats is essential. Regularly scheduled training sessions, workshops, and simulations can help keep employees engaged and informed about the latest tactics employed by hackers. By integrating lessons on cognitive biases into these educational initiatives, organizations can better prepare their workforce to recognize and resist attempts to exploit their attention and emotional responses. Ultimately, a proactive approach to understanding and mitigating the effects of cognitive biases will enhance overall security measures and protect sensitive information from potential breaches.


Meet The Social Engineer

Joshua Crumbaugh

Joshua Crumbaugh
Recognizing the challenges and variation in applying psychology theory to real-world environments, I founded PhishFirewall, a security awareness and phishing training company built on these principles I’ve spent my career refining. We test and apply these concepts in diverse and practical ways to fit each organization’s unique needs.

I invite you to benchmark my company and discover how even slight changes in your approach can yield tremendous impacts on your organization’s security posture.

Hi, I’m Joshua Crumbaugh, and I’m proud to say that for over 20 years, I’ve been one of the leading Ethical Hackers in the United States. I’ve had the privilege of leading Red Teams for Fortune 500 companies, banks, governments, and large-scale enterprises, and and I routinely advises law enforcement agencies across the country and other industry leaders on emerging threats posed by human vulnerability.

The constant evolution of technology has advanced the tradecraft of exploiting people, but the good news is that people can be trained to become the most effective line of defense in any organization. Let’s work together to turn your people into your strongest line of defense.

What is PhishFirewall?

PhishFirewall is an emerging leader in people cybersecurity solutions designed to stop users from clicking on phish and empowers them to operate securely in the workplace.

AI autonomously delivers comprehensive awareness training and phishing simulations to optimize an organization's security posture and provides a one stop solution for industry specific compliance requirements. Unlike traditional tools, it provides zero campaign management, allowing administrators to strategically manage their priorities, with the added benefit of offering a streamlined, one-time setup with ongoing personalized training.
Key Benefits
Fully automate administrative management, reporting, and "just in time" communications.
Reduce organizational risk by 34% through customized training.
Increase employee engagement and performance by 42% without the punitive measures
“You set your people up in this system, and it just does it. It does it all."
– CISO, State Government
>80,000 Employees
“Once you see this in action, you can’t go back to the old way of training and testing.”
– CEO, Major Logistics Firm
>10,000 Employees
“This is security training 2.0, even the doctors do it!”
– CISO, Large Hospital
>30,000 Emoloyees

Key Features

Role-Based Phishing and Training

Tailor phishing simulations and training to each user’s role within the organization.

Customized Interaction and Testing

Adaptive training and testing based on individual performance and vulnerabilities for a personalized growth experience.

60-Second Training Modules

Quick, impactful training modules delivered in 60 seconds or less to fit seamlessly into your employees' day scaled at the frequency you want.

Complete Compliance Frameworks

Tailor phishing simulations and training to each user’s role within the organization.

Fast-Track Compliance

Accelerate your path to compliance with streamlined onboarding.

“Report a Phish” Button

Empower users to report suspicious emails with one click, improving overall security, speed of containment, and reduce the reach within the organization.

Multi-Language Delivery

Connect a global audience with training modules available in multiple languages.

Dual Coding Engagement

Enhance learning retention through dual coding techniques for better understanding and performance.

Extensive Training Library

Access a vast library of training materials that cover a wide range of security topics.

Customizable Training Modules

Create and deploy your own training modules to address specific needs within your organization.

Auto-Generated Reporting

Easily access automated reports that track progress and highlight areas for improvement.

User Report Cards

Provide individual feedback through user report cards, helping employees track their performance.

Organizational Leaderboards and Summaries

Foster healthy competition and track overall progress with organizational leaderboards and performance summaries.

Interactive Charts and Graphs

View trend analysis and performance distributions in real-time through dynamic, easy-to-read charts and tables.

Best-in-Class Administrative Dashboards

Manage your training programs effortlessly with intuitive, best-in-class dashboards designed for ease of use.

One-Day Setup

Get up and running quickly with a setup process that takes just a few hours.

Scalability

Effortlessly onboard new users and can be scaled to an organization of any size.

More In the Pipeline

We are always striving to innovate, and create the features that solve your problems!
Exclusive Offer!

Get Free Security Awareness Posters Today!

Secure your office with this months free security awareness posters!
PosterPosterPoster