Testing effect

Category:

What Should We Remember?

Definition:

The phenomenon where retrieving information from memory during a test improves long-term retention more than simply re-reading the information.

Published on
September 4, 2024
Updated on
September 4, 2024
What Should We Remember?

Learning Objectives

What you will learn:
Understand the concept of the Testing effect
Recognize the Impact of the Testing effect in cybersecurity
Strategies to mitigate Testing effect

Other Cognitive Biases

Author

Joshua Crumbaugh
Joshua Crumbaugh
Social Engineer

Subscribe to our newsletter

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

The Psychology behind the Testing effect:

The testing effect operates on several psychological principles that highlight the significance of active engagement in the learning process. When individuals retrieve information from memory, they are not merely recalling facts; they are reinforcing neural pathways associated with that information. This retrieval process stimulates deeper cognitive processing, which enhances understanding and retention. Psychologically, the act of testing ourselves creates a form of cognitive rehearsal that solidifies knowledge more effectively than passive review methods such as re-reading or highlighting. The repeated retrieval of information fosters a sense of familiarity and confidence, which can further motivate learners to engage with the material.


Moreover, the testing effect underscores the importance of metacognition—the awareness and regulation of one's learning strategies. When learners test themselves, they become more aware of what they know and what they need to study further. This self-assessment promotes adaptive learning strategies, allowing individuals to identify gaps in their knowledge and concentrate their efforts on areas that require improvement. In essence, the testing effect not only boosts memory retention but also cultivates a more effective learning mindset, encouraging learners to take an active role in their educational journeys. By emphasizing the retrieval of information, the testing effect helps to establish a more durable and organized memory, ultimately facilitating deeper comprehension and long-term retention of knowledge.

How To Differentiate the Testing effect from other cognitive biases?

The testing effect is meaningfully distinct from other cognitive biases in the "What Should We Remember?" category because it emphasizes the active retrieval of information as a critical mechanism for enhancing memory retention. Unlike biases that focus on how memories are encoded or stored, the testing effect highlights the role of retrieval practice in solidifying knowledge. This difference underscores the importance of engaging with material through testing rather than passive review, leading to more effective learning outcomes.

How does the Testing effect apply to Business Operations?

Scenario:

In a cybersecurity training program for employees, a company decides to implement a series of assessments to reinforce learning about phishing attacks and data security protocols. Employees initially undergo a comprehensive training session, focusing on key concepts and strategies to identify potential threats. Following the training, instead of simply re-reading materials or watching videos, the company introduces regular quizzes and interactive testing sessions to gauge understanding and retention of the material.


Application:

The cybersecurity team creates a schedule where employees engage in short, frequent quizzes after each training module. These quizzes include multiple-choice questions and scenario-based assessments that require employees to apply what they've learned. By actively retrieving information, employees reinforce their knowledge and identify areas where they need further review. This approach contrasts with traditional methods where employees might only review the training materials passively without any testing.


Results:

After several months of incorporating the testing effect into their training program, the company observes a significant increase in employees' ability to recognize phishing attempts and adhere to security protocols. Follow-up assessments reveal that employees who participated in the testing sessions score 30% higher than those who only re-read the materials. Additionally, there is a noticeable decrease in security incidents related to phishing, suggesting that the active retrieval methods have had a positive impact on their practical application of the knowledge gained.


Conclusion:

This example demonstrates how the testing effect can be effectively utilized in cybersecurity training to enhance memory retention and application of knowledge. By prioritizing active retrieval through quizzes and testing, businesses can cultivate a more informed workforce, leading to improved security practices and reduced vulnerability to cyber threats. The emphasis on retrieval not only strengthens memory but also fosters a proactive learning environment, equipping employees with the skills needed to navigate an increasingly complex cybersecurity landscape.


How do Hackers Exploit the Testing effect?

Scenario:

A social engineer conducts a targeted phishing campaign against a company to extract sensitive information from employees. The social engineer sends emails that appear to come from a trusted source within the organization, encouraging employees to click on links that lead to fake login pages designed to capture their credentials. Recognizing the importance of employee awareness, the company implements a training program that leverages the testing effect to enhance employees' ability to identify and respond to such threats.


Application:

The company develops an interactive training module that includes real-world phishing scenarios, followed by assessments that require employees to identify phishing attempts. After the initial training session, employees engage in regular testing through simulated phishing emails sent to their inboxes. These tests not only require employees to recognize and report potential threats but also reinforce their learning by actively retrieving information about phishing signs and security protocols. Feedback is provided immediately, allowing employees to understand their mistakes and learn from them.


Results:

Over the course of a few months, the company observes a marked improvement in employees' ability to detect phishing attempts. Follow-up assessments reveal that employees who participated in the active testing sessions are 40% more likely to successfully identify phishing emails compared to those who did not undergo the training. Additionally, the company reports a significant decrease in successful phishing attacks, with only 5% of employees falling victim to simulated phishing attempts, compared to 25% before the implementation of the training program.


Conclusion:

This example illustrates how the testing effect can be utilized to combat social engineering threats within a business. By incorporating active retrieval practices in employee training, companies can enhance their workforce's awareness and preparedness against phishing attacks. The emphasis on testing not only strengthens memory retention but also builds a culture of vigilance, ultimately reducing the risk of security breaches and protecting sensitive information from social engineering tactics.


How To Minimize the effect of the Testing effect across your organization?

Defending against the cognitive bias associated with the testing effect can play a crucial role in preventing hackers from exploiting organizational vulnerabilities. One key strategy is to foster a culture of continuous learning and engagement within the workplace. Management should encourage employees to actively participate in their training processes, emphasizing the importance of not just passively consuming information but also retrieving and applying it in real-world contexts. Regularly scheduled quizzes, practical tests, and scenario-based assessments can be integrated into ongoing training programs to create a dynamic learning environment. This not only enhances knowledge retention but also empowers employees to recognize and respond effectively to potential security threats.


Another effective approach is to implement a structured feedback mechanism that helps employees understand their strengths and weaknesses regarding cybersecurity awareness. By providing timely and constructive feedback on performance during testing sessions, management can foster metacognitive skills among employees. This self-awareness allows individuals to identify gaps in their knowledge and take proactive steps to address them. For instance, after a testing session, employees can be directed to specific resources or additional training materials tailored to their identified weaknesses. This individualized approach not only reinforces learning but also builds confidence, enabling employees to better navigate cybersecurity challenges.


Moreover, management should be vigilant about the potential for cognitive biases to influence decision-making processes, particularly in high-stakes situations where security is concerned. By cultivating an awareness of biases, leaders can implement strategies that mitigate their impact. For instance, fostering open communication and collaboration among teams can help counteract overconfidence in one's knowledge or skills, encouraging employees to seek clarification when uncertain. Additionally, promoting diverse perspectives in discussions about security protocols can help identify blind spots that may arise from groupthink, ultimately leading to more robust security strategies and practices.


Finally, organizations can leverage technology to enhance the effectiveness of their training programs and mitigate the risks associated with cognitive biases. By utilizing automated systems for simulated phishing attacks and other social engineering tests, companies can create a controlled environment for employees to practice their skills. These simulations can provide immediate feedback and reinforce learning, ensuring that employees remain engaged and vigilant. Furthermore, data analytics can be employed to track performance trends over time, allowing management to adjust training initiatives based on observed patterns. By combining active retrieval methods with technological advancements, organizations can create a resilient workforce capable of defending against evolving cyber threats.


Meet The Social Engineer

Joshua Crumbaugh

Joshua Crumbaugh
Recognizing the challenges and variation in applying psychology theory to real-world environments, I founded PhishFirewall, a security awareness and phishing training company built on these principles I’ve spent my career refining. We test and apply these concepts in diverse and practical ways to fit each organization’s unique needs.

I invite you to benchmark my company and discover how even slight changes in your approach can yield tremendous impacts on your organization’s security posture.

Hi, I’m Joshua Crumbaugh, and I’m proud to say that for over 20 years, I’ve been one of the leading Ethical Hackers in the United States. I’ve had the privilege of leading Red Teams for Fortune 500 companies, banks, governments, and large-scale enterprises, and and I routinely advises law enforcement agencies across the country and other industry leaders on emerging threats posed by human vulnerability.

The constant evolution of technology has advanced the tradecraft of exploiting people, but the good news is that people can be trained to become the most effective line of defense in any organization. Let’s work together to turn your people into your strongest line of defense.

What is PhishFirewall?

PhishFirewall is an emerging leader in people cybersecurity solutions designed to stop users from clicking on phish and empowers them to operate securely in the workplace.

AI autonomously delivers comprehensive awareness training and phishing simulations to optimize an organization's security posture and provides a one stop solution for industry specific compliance requirements. Unlike traditional tools, it provides zero campaign management, allowing administrators to strategically manage their priorities, with the added benefit of offering a streamlined, one-time setup with ongoing personalized training.
Key Benefits
Fully automate administrative management, reporting, and "just in time" communications.
Reduce organizational risk by 34% through customized training.
Increase employee engagement and performance by 42% without the punitive measures
“You set your people up in this system, and it just does it. It does it all."
– CISO, State Government
>80,000 Employees
“Once you see this in action, you can’t go back to the old way of training and testing.”
– CEO, Major Logistics Firm
>10,000 Employees
“This is security training 2.0, even the doctors do it!”
– CISO, Large Hospital
>30,000 Emoloyees

Key Features

Role-Based Phishing and Training

Tailor phishing simulations and training to each user’s role within the organization.

Customized Interaction and Testing

Adaptive training and testing based on individual performance and vulnerabilities for a personalized growth experience.

60-Second Training Modules

Quick, impactful training modules delivered in 60 seconds or less to fit seamlessly into your employees' day scaled at the frequency you want.

Complete Compliance Frameworks

Tailor phishing simulations and training to each user’s role within the organization.

Fast-Track Compliance

Accelerate your path to compliance with streamlined onboarding.

“Report a Phish” Button

Empower users to report suspicious emails with one click, improving overall security, speed of containment, and reduce the reach within the organization.

Multi-Language Delivery

Connect a global audience with training modules available in multiple languages.

Dual Coding Engagement

Enhance learning retention through dual coding techniques for better understanding and performance.

Extensive Training Library

Access a vast library of training materials that cover a wide range of security topics.

Customizable Training Modules

Create and deploy your own training modules to address specific needs within your organization.

Auto-Generated Reporting

Easily access automated reports that track progress and highlight areas for improvement.

User Report Cards

Provide individual feedback through user report cards, helping employees track their performance.

Organizational Leaderboards and Summaries

Foster healthy competition and track overall progress with organizational leaderboards and performance summaries.

Interactive Charts and Graphs

View trend analysis and performance distributions in real-time through dynamic, easy-to-read charts and tables.

Best-in-Class Administrative Dashboards

Manage your training programs effortlessly with intuitive, best-in-class dashboards designed for ease of use.

One-Day Setup

Get up and running quickly with a setup process that takes just a few hours.

Scalability

Effortlessly onboard new users and can be scaled to an organization of any size.

More In the Pipeline

We are always striving to innovate, and create the features that solve your problems!
Exclusive Offer!

Get Free Security Awareness Posters Today!

Secure your office with this months free security awareness posters!
PosterPosterPoster