Cybersecurity: Guardian or Tyrant? The Hidden Icebergs in Corporate Waters

The most dangerous iceberg is not the one you see but the one you don't. Such is the case in the corporate world where, beneath the surface, there lurks a growing yet less explored threat: toxic cybersecurity teams. Driven by fear of ransomware attacks and data breaches, organizations often give these teams unchecked authority. However, this unchecked authority is gradually leading us into riskier cyber territories, according to cybersecurity experts.

The problem isn't so much the existence of cybersecurity teams - they are, undeniably, a necessary entity. The issue lies in their unchecked conduct and often harmful practices that threaten the overall harmony and functionality of the enterprise. Let's delve into some of these toxic behaviors and explore why they're more dangerous than we've perceived them to be.

Phishing Simulations - A Double-Edged Sword: The most familiar of these practices is the classic "Three strikes and you're out" or even "Five strikes and you're out" approach to phishing simulations. The intent behind these simulations is noble: to educate and protect. However, the execution often leans more towards humiliation than education, which is not only counterproductive but harmful. Users are sometimes exploited during these exercises, a practice that is both ethically and professionally inexcusable except during explicit red team or penetration testing exercises.

The 'My Way or the Highway' Approach: One of the most prevalent attitudes in the cybersecurity industry is this god-like complex, a belief that their solutions and methods are absolute. This attitude overlooks the reality that cybersecurity is not the be-all-end-all of an organization. It is, instead, a part of a greater whole. The cybersecurity team's role is not to eliminate risk entirely but to effectively communicate and offer alternatives to mitigate such risks, allowing the C-suite to make informed decisions.

The God Complex: Cybersecurity professionals often see themselves as superior beings in the corporate hierarchy, which isn't just detrimental but an outright delusion. Derogatory terms such as PEBCAK (Problem Exists Between Chair And Keyboard), PICNIC (Problem In Chair Not In Computer), or ID10T errors further reinforce this perception. The truth, however, is simple: every department, every employee, has a unique role and expertise. Cybersecurity teams are not superior; they are part of a symbiotic system.

User Exploitation: Cybersecurity's responsibility extends beyond identifying and protecting against external threats; it involves respecting and protecting internal stakeholders too. Features like phishing simulations, which check whether users will type in their login credentials, are examples of overreach and abuse of power. Such practices exploit users and create a hostile work environment. The focus should be on just-in-time education which fosters a culture of learning and growth rather than fear and reprimand.

Punitive practices like these stifle innovation, creativity, and risk-taking - the lifeblood of any successful organization. They breed fear, suppress potential whistleblowers, and degrade overall engagement. Organizations must establish clear boundaries about what cybersecurity teams can and cannot do when dealing with their fellow employees. They should not let the fear of external threats blind them to the internal ones.

Ultimately, it's about creating a culture of respect, cooperation, and shared responsibility. It's about navigating the cyber seas together, not sinking the corporate ship. Because when cybersecurity teams function harmoniously with the rest of the organization, they form a united front against external threats, becoming an asset rather than a liability.

Organizations need to foster a culture of mutual respect, cooperation, and shared responsibility, where cybersecurity is seen as a collective effort rather than a punishing regime. It's about sailing the cyber seas together, without capsizing the corporate ship. The key is harmonious integration, where cybersecurity teams serve as valuable allies, not fear-inducing adversaries. Only then can organizations genuinely safeguard their digital assets while preserving the innovation, creativity, and risk-taking spirit that is the lifeblood of successful enterprises.

PhishFirewall addresses these issues head-on by flipping the script on traditional, punitive cybersecurity practices. Through our non-punitive, gamified platform, we foster a friendly and engaging environment for phishing simulation and security awareness training. We believe that cybersecurity doesn't have to be a scary, punitive regime but rather a journey of continuous learning, collaboration, and growth. PhishFirewall's focus is not to exploit vulnerabilities but to empower individuals, offering them the tools, resources, and confidence they need to protect themselves and their organization. In this way, we aim to turn cybersecurity from a perceived liability into an asset, promoting a culture of shared responsibility and respect. In the grand voyage of the cyber seas, PhishFirewall serves as a lighthouse, guiding organizations safely through the shifting tides of digital threats.

‍